Back in December, the Yankees announced they were bringing back RHP Paul Blackburn on a one-year, $2 million contract. Rather than evaluating the signing itself, frustrated fans used the move to vent about the broader offseason, with fans on X rattling off “worst offseason ever” claims and dismissing the deal as “dumpster diving.” Just over six months later, the 32-year-old has put together a career year, giving the Yankees valuable outs whenever his number is called.
However, it is remarkable that Blackburn has even reached this point wearing Yankee pinstripes.
The Yankees signed Blackburn in August 2025 after the crosstown rival Mets designated him for assignment. Just two days after switching clubhouses, Blackburn took the mound in a game the Yankees were already trailing 5-1. The right-hander retired the side over his first two innings of work before being shelled in the ninth inning for seven runs on as many hits in a 12-1 thumping by the Red Sox.
Fortunately for both Blackburn and the Yankees, that outing proved to be an anomaly. Over his next seven outings, he allowed just two earned runs in 12 innings of work to earn a spot on the postseason roster.
His lone postseason outing, however, looked much more like his Yankee debut. Blackburn surrendered four runs on six hits in just 1.1 innings in a disastrous ALDS Game 1 loss to Toronto. It was exactly the kind of uninspiring note that fed the pessimistic social media reaction come winter. Blackburn was viewed as a low-risk, easily forgettable aging reliever.
Instead, Blackburn has spent the first half of 2026 making many eat their words.
Initially expected to fill a bulk-relief role, Blackburn has since developed into one of Aaron Boone’s most trusted middle-inning options. As of the Yankees’ July 3 win over Minnesota, he owns a 2.34 ERA and a 1.13 WHIP across 28 appearances.
While Blackburn is not blowing away hitters, he excels at neutralizing traffic by inducing ground balls and weak contact. The soft-contact specialist owns a 57.6% ground-ball rate, a career high that ranks in the 97th percentile among major league pitchers. Even when hitters are not on top of the ball, Blackburn has kept the quality of contact soft. He sits in the top 40 among major-league arms in average exit velocity allowed.
His breakout isn’t simply the result of better execution, though. It is the product of a completely different approach. Working exclusively out of the bullpen is new to Blackburn. Before dawning Yankee pinstripes, 86 of Blackburn’s 93 career appearances were starts. The move to the bullpen has allowed the veteran’s pitch mix to play up in ways it never did as a starter.
The former All-Star, who earned that honor with the Athletics in 2022, averaged just 91.7 mph in his fastball that season. Now, rather than trying to ration his velocity over five or six innings, the 32-year-old is attacking hitters with a career-best average fastball velocity of 94.2 mph.
Blackburn has leaned heavily on his sinker-cutter combination to tie up right-handed hitters while using an improved changeup, curveball and sweeper to keep lefties off balance. In fact, opponents are hitting below .120 against each of those three secondary pitches after batting over .250 against all three just a season ago.
Before June 1, Blackburn was a serviceable but occasionally erratic option, striking out 16 and walking 11 over 24.1 innings. Since then, he has allowed just two earned runs over his last 18 innings of work while issuing only two walks. Zoom out even further, and the numbers become even more impressive. Since allowing three runs against Baltimore on May 13, Blackburn has posted a microscopic 1.09 ERA, the third-best mark in Major League Baseball over that span, trailing only Brewers superstar Jacob Misiorowski and fellow Yankees reliever Brent Headrick.
What was once mocked on social media as an uninspiring depth signing has instead become one of the Yankees’ biggest surprises. Where the club needed a cheap, reliable arm to bridge the gap to the late innings, they didn’t just find insurance; they found a weapon.
The Yankee Office 
Leave a comment